“Vanessa Carlton is a formidable artist.” – Variety
“Carlton’s version is as gentle as the original, with ephemeral harmonies that layer a gauzy romanticism over Carlton’s starry-eyed vocals.” – Consequence of Sound
“Vanessa Carlton keeps slaying the cover game with a gorgeous take on Fleetwood Mac” – Fuse
“The artist behind the track that has inspired an endless list of pop culture references has covered a song as coverable as her own: Robyn’s ‘Call Your Girlfriend.'” – Stereogum
“Vanessa Carlton has refined her voice as a songwriter.” – Rolling Stone
“Carlton’s voice is the key attraction on songs that register between low-key pop, rock, and folk.” – Pitchfork
“…she’s back, she’s dreamy, there’s some sort of arty thing going on here, she’s moved to Nashville, had a baby girl with Deer Tick’s John McCauley, and simply sounds better than ever.” – Yahoo